原帖引用 · AI 翻译
标题:“规划智能体应如何重塑其搜索空间?”
卡内基梅隆大学的一篇新论文发现,规划旅行和购物的 AI 助手,与其询问人们的偏好,不如向他们展示几个真实选项,这样能找到更多人们愿意接受的选择。
像“评分在 3.8 或以上的餐厅”这样的旅行需求,会排除一家评分为 3.7、价格更低,而用户其实很愿意选的餐厅。人们很少会主动说自己愿意为了省钱接受较低的评分,因为只有看到实际选项时,他们才会意识到这一点。
> 在使用同一个规划器的情况下,将这 1 个未明说的取舍加入需求后,用户接受的方案比例从 12% 提高到 55%。
> 当前的智能体(Claude Code、Gemini CLI 等)大多只是提问,很少展示方案,因此最多只能发现用户愿意接受的方案中的 32%。
> 展示方案的智能体明显比提问的智能体表现更好。
当你的智能体把需求转化为方案时,应在确定需求细则之前,尽早向用户展示几个超出其明示限制的选项。
原文
New Carnegie Mellon paper finds that AI assistants that plan trips and shopping find more options people would accept by showing them a few real choices than by asking about their preferences. A travel request like “restaurants rated 3.8 or higher” throws out a cheaper place rated 3.7 that the user would happily pick. People rarely say they would accept a lower rating to save money, because they only realize it when they see the actual options. > Adding that 1 hidden trade-off to the request raised the share of plans the user accepted from 12% to 55%, with the same planner. > Current agents (Claude Code, Gemini CLI and others) mostly asked questions and rarely showed plans, so they caught at most 32% of plans the user would accept. > Agents that showed plans did clearly better than agents that asked. When your agent turns a request into a plan, show the user a few options outside their stated limits early, before locking the spec.