Original post · Original
The article text is unavailable in this language; an existing version is shown.
Rohan Paul@rohanpaul_ai
Title: "The Critic Can Hurt: On the Safety of Critics in LLM-Guided AutoML Search"
New Amazon + University of Massachusetts paper finds that adding an LLM critic to a search loop has small upside, about 0.005 AUC at best, and much larger downside.
Weak LLM critic can push AutoML search below plain random search
Agent systems often add an LLM critic that reads past results and tells the search what to try next. Teams check whether it helps, rarely whether it hurts.
They ran the same tabular model search with and without a critic, over a fixed pool of 96 pipeline setups. Random critic mistakes cost almost nothing since the loop keeps its best result, but advice that steadily points the wrong way wastes tries.
A Llama-3.1-8B critic scored below the no-critic baseline on 7 of 8 datasets, losing up to 0.245 AUC. An ideal critic gained at most about 0.005 AUC, and the harm mostly faded with 250 setups and 20 rounds.
Before trusting an LLM critic, even a large one, run the same budget without it and drop it if it loses.
View this post on X ↗
· UTC+8